Tuesday, January 29, 2013

I'm Sorry, but I'm Not.

{Disclaimer: This post is not intended to offend anyone or push my beliefs on any of my readers. It is simply an explanation to a comment that I received. I apologize in advance for the length, but I had a lot to say.}

This past Saturday, I posted a video about being Pro-Life. You can see the original post here. Before I hit "publish," I debated whether or not I should actually post it. I am not a very political person, and I didn't want the post to be viewed as such. I am, however, a religious person, and I just felt like it was a beautiful video that I wanted to share with my family and friends on my blog.

Unfortunately, I got an email yesterday from an anonymous blogger who appears to have followed my blog for awhile or at least read multiple posts before making her comment, and it didn't sit well with me. In fact, it was the first time that I felt like I had been attacked personally via my blog. I don't know if she's even still reading/following, but if so, I wanted to explain myself. {As well as for any of you who may feel the same way as she does.}

{The red, italicized portions are her words with my views in regular font.}

Although you view your two fetuses as precious blessings (and that's great) for me a fetus simply represents a terrible 18+ year burden, and a potential threat to my life. Do you really want a world of forced pregnancy? If I were to become pregnant - I would be proud of my abortion: a decision that would protect my hopes and dreams for the future. Also, a significant reduction in the murder rate occurred in the late 80's - which many research suggests is linked to the beginning of Roe v. Wade and a reduction of children growing up in lower socio-economic areas where they may be more prone to being victims or criminals.

A terrible 18+ year burden? Are you serious that there would be NOTHING positive about raising another life?? Sure, I know that there are times when my brother and I made things difficult for my parents, and I know that raising Liam and our other future children is not going to be a walk in the park. However, I also know that the good times will far outweigh the bad. Even now, approaching 30 years old, I treasure my time spent shopping with my mom at the mall, grabbing lunch with her, running with my dad, or family vacations together, and I can't wait to share those experiences with TJ and our children when they're older.

I very well understand that pregnancy does not always go smoothly. I probably understand this fact much better than the general population. I have actually taken care of many pregnant women as their physician, and I have spent countless hours in the hospital witnessing complicated pregnancies and the potential outcomes, both good and bad. But do you know what else is a threat to life, and much more widespread than pregnancy? Smoking and obesity. Two things that I try to combat MULTIPLE TIMES A DAY, EVERY DAY in my career as a family medicine physician. Those two things cause many, many more deaths each year than pregnancy. In fact, obesity is starting to kill our kids too.

Maybe that study did show a correlation, maybe it did not. Has that trend continued today? Show me the study; I'll read it. The way I look at it, even if it did show a decreased murder rate, people {fetuses WITH a heartbeat} were murdered in the first place. Is that really winning?

I am strongly childfree-by-choice and I intend to remain that way. My career is the most significant part of my identity and I don't want the interference of a fetus during pregnancy, and an infant/small child after birth that continues for the next 18+ years.

First of all, if your career is your whole identity, and you put your career before your family and/or husband, I feel sorry for them. I have spent the last TWELVE YEARS of my life in school {college and medical school - 8 years} or training {residency and fellowship - 4 more years} to become a physician. I have spent HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of dollars in order to achieve my long time dream of becoming a doctor. I have spent countless hours in the hospital {sometimes 30 hours in a row, sometimes 80 hours a week} in order to care for other people's families when I am missing spending time with my own. There is no doubt that my career is a significant part of my identity, and always will be, but it isn't everything. When I have the choice, I don't put my job before my husband, and I certainly will not put it before Liam and the rest of our kids. Does that mean I'm not putting my whole heart and soul into my career? Absolutely not. When I am in an exam room with a patient, I do everything I can in my power to get them back to health, whether that is giving antibiotics to a kid with an ear infection or giving life-saving medicine to a middle-aged female with uncontrolled diabetes and hypertension or just sitting and listening while my patient sheds tears about her family stressors. At that moment, I am not thinking about my family; I am treating my patient like my own mother or father or child...that is what I am called to do as a physician.

Thankfully, I am blessed in the fact that my workplace is very understanding, and I have the time to go to my prenatal appointments, have time off for maternity leave, etc. Some of my female colleagues have had complications such as threatened preterm labor, and what did we do? We worked together to make sure her patients were seen and her hospital shifts were covered. I have no idea if complications will arise later on in this pregnancy...Will have to be on bedrest? Will I deliver early? I certainly hope none of the bad things happen, but, in the end, we never know when we are going to be sick, have a major accident, or have a family crisis. If you're so worried about that stuff happening to you, maybe you should just not work at all. It's just something on which you have to take a leap of faith.

I have NO problem with someone making the choice to remain childless. Being a parent is not for everyone. However, I don't think you should attack a woman with a career for her desire to have both a career AND a family.

As a successful female, I'm curious how you reconcile the inherent misogyny of the Catholic faith. Why do you want to raise a child in a religion that does not recognize women as leaders, in addition to endorsing an all-male trinity?

I'm pretty sure it's well-established, believed, and accepted that Jesus was male, the son of God. I can't change that fact; it just is. The Holy Trinity consists of the Father {God}, Son {Jesus}, and the Holy Spirit. I can't change that either. As far as women leaders, the Catholic Church was established on the rock of St. Peter {Matthew 16:18}. The Catholic Church is based on Apostolic succession, meaning that the popes come from the line of the apostles, which is why they are always men, and probaly always will be. TJ and I want to raise our children in the Catholic faith because it is what we believe. The fact that women cannot be priests, bishops, cardinals, or popes is not the deciding factor for us. If that would be the deciding factor for you, then you are missing the point. Big time. Women are a big part of the church. Have you ever heard of nuns or the religious life? In our Parish, the women of the church have a large leadership role, from planning the liturgy to running the Parish office to sitting on Parish Council. My mom even leads one of the committees. It may not be the type of leadership you are thinking of, but it is still leadership, nonetheless.

From reading your blog, it seems you endorse somewhat degrading gender roles in your marriage. You seem to the primary one cooking and completing household tasks. You've also mentioned you hope to work part-time. Hopefully, our generation will be the first for women not to compromise career aspirations because of silly notions of motherhood. For example, if I were to have a child why should I have to waste more of my time away from my career caring for it than the child's father? For someone with a college education {let alone an advanced degree} are the tasks of caring for children really more important than working?

Really? You want to bring up gender roles...okay, fine. Sure, I do almost all the cooking, I do a fair amount of the cleaning, and I do the laundry too. However, TJ doesn't like to cook, and I enjoy it, so I don't mind it...at least most nights. TJ helps with the cleaning when I ask him to, he almost always unloads the dishwasher {without me even asking}, and he helps fold the laundry too. We both pay bills. We both work and contribute to our bank account. However, you must have missed the fact that I am a doctor, and my husband and I both understand {and are okay with} the fact that I will always be the breadwinner of the family. Tell me how that falls into the traditional gender roles. I certainly have not {and will not} compromise my career aspirations because of my "silly notion of motherhood." What part of twelve years of school and training did you not understand? Even if I had gotten pregnant as a first year resident, I wouldn't have given up my dream of becoming a sports medicine physician. No way.

You're correct in saying that I want to work part-time someday. I am lucky that even if I want to work part-time as a physician, we will still be able to live a comfortable life. I see it as the best of both worlds...continuing my career that I have worked SO HARD to achieve, but also spending time with my family which is even more important. I can't even comprehend how that would be "wasting time." There's also something called daycare, which we will be utilizing in the future. It was created so that people {including women} could continue to work in order to provide for their children and families. Just because a woman has a baby doesn't mean that she is forced to stay home with them until they are 18 years of age {as you make it sound}. A baby is not a death sentence and an end to a career.

With all that said, yes, I am Pro-Life. When it comes down to it, the Fifth Commandment states "Thou shall not kill." I can't argue with that.

~~~~~

If you have made it this far, thank you. I had a lot to get off my chest. I have decided to leave Saturday's post up, as well as the anonymous comment. I have, however, closed that post for future comments. I am leaving the comments open on this post. Unfortunately, I am no longer allowing anonymous comments.

Thanks for reading.

25 comments:

Katie said...

Holy poop, Emily! What a crazy (and cowardly anonymous) comment to get. You did a great job expressing yourself and your beliefs without attacking back :) and for the record, I second everything you said!

Ashley said...

Wow... that reader hopped off the crazy train... I find her comment very rude and degrading. What about all those people waiting for a baby? Although I am afraid I wouldnt want to hear the answer! Good job for standing up to this type of bullying!

Amanda said...

Sing your praises! God is in Heaven right now proud of this post. We are to give Him all the glory and follow His word! Pro-life!

Amy Grace said...

Oh Emily, I'm so sorry you had to deal with that! That person has a twisted view of life and priorities for a happy, well balanced home. She is so out of line to speak so harshly. It's really sad to see how she doesn't value family or kids. I'm not catholic--I use birth control--but I know that when my husband and I get pregnant, we will be so happy because family brings more joy than almost anything else in life. I can't wait to be a mother, and while this anonymous writer may not have the same goals, she shouldn't be attacking you for wanting to have kids and start the most exciting journey of your life.

Much love to you and TJ!

Nikki said...

Emily I am so so sorry you had to deal with such ignorance! Kudos to you for following your dream of being a doctor and becoming a mother! Don't let someone like that bring you down. The way I see it is she has issues with herself she needs to deal with. I almost feel like she is jealous of you and our life as well.

Unknown said...

Great response Emily! The 18+ burden is the most disturbing of her whole message. I know we can't change everyone's minds about their beliefs, but hopefully your message shed some light.

Callie said...

Oh wow. Just wow. I think you responded very well to the comment Emily, I can't understand that kind of thinking at all. The "silly notion of motherhood"? I think godly children are the greatest thing you can leave behind - they are a legacy. That's not "silly", and I think only short-sighted people would think it is.

Lauren said...

I'm shocked by the email you received. I, too, have had many years of schooling to get to where I am, but my unborn child and my husband take precedence. I am so blessed to work in an office where family comes first and that I do not have to choose between my career and my loved ones.

Daycare is a wonderful thing. No doubt, it will be difficult to leave my child there, but the benefits of me continuing my career and sustaining our quality of life are worth it in the end.

Callie said...

P. S. Conpletely agree with you on your pro-life stance too, and I'm proud of you for speaking out! I hope you won't let people like this person discourage you from standing up for what's right in the future too!

Donna said...

you go...my baby girl! So proud to be your mama!

Maggie said...

Just had a chance to read your post from Saturday and watch the video. It was so beautiful and I loved the Scripture references - what an amazing reminder of God's goodness. Thank you for that!

I'm sorry a person brought negativity to your blog. I think you responded so well. Can't wait to read about all the goodies you registered for sweet Liam! XO

Natalie | Mrs. Janney | said...

So many things that person wrote to you made me want to scream. Seriously. Who says those kinds of things to people?!?

I loved your response.

The Unlikely Runner said...

Wow, I commend you greatly for the way you handled your response! It is always so amazing to me that people feel the need to force their opinions upon people and then do so in such a hateful way. I think that you presented yourself correctly and I applaud you and TJ for the future you have ahead of you. May God bless you both and your future family.

Emily said...

Wow. I have no idea what to even say! We are Catholic, too, and as I read the anonymous comments all I could think was, "seriously??" Great response, Emily!

Lauren {at} Life.Love.Lauren said...

I mean if I am going to play devil's advocate here, that was not the best way to advocate for the pro choice side of things...jeez. Keep on keeping on! You rock!

Ellen A. said...

Thanks for taking the time to respectfully respond to such a disrespectful comment. No one is forcing that woman to get pregant. I know the Catholic church is against birth control, but no one is stopping her from using it. If she doesn't want to be pregnant, her choice, but don't get pregnant and selfishly kill an innocent child. She doesn't have to raise that child, but I guarantee someone in this world would love that child very much.

Unknown said...

Oo Love! I think you are definitely entitled to your opinion! And although, it is a controversial topic, it is one of the new millennia. Some people are rooted in much older ideals/gender roles. I completely understand and support your point of view. As health care provider myself, I am still debating the child-free choice because I am so tied to all of the specifics you mention. It is a complicated topic, and sometimes a complicated choice. And to each their own. This is definitely a space to share your thoughts freely... without scrutiny (in a perfect world). Cheers to a very happy and successful career love!

Laura said...

oh wow! I am so sorry that you had to go through that. Each of us is entitled to our own opinion and the last time I checked, this was YOUR blog! I am glad and proud of you for standing up for your beliefs. Being one that has had a miscarriage too, I totally agree with you. There are so many families that thank God everyday for the birth mother who chose adoption over abortion.

you go girl!

Curvy Academic said...

http://pricetheory.uchicago.edu/levitt/Papers/DonohueLevittTheImpactOfLegalized2001.pdf

The research I should have listed in my last post.

I stand by my statement that my career is my number one passion in life. Having a child would undoubtedly, at times, interfere with my career. To me it is not worth making any sacrifice in my career or the non-work parts of my life I enjoy.

I love my husband and he is a great support system for my life - I am also the primary wage earner - but my career the main part of my identity.

People have different values and priorities - putting one's career ahead of family is not wrong, just different.

There are a myriad of reasons why I do not want children to be a part of my life. I do not want the burden of caring for it (even equally with my husband) during the younger years when it cannot complete basic care tasks. From watching-observing others (my husband has teenage children that spend time with us, and I worked in childcare in college) I am confident I would not enjoy this. I also greatly value time to myself and hate having extra errands and places to go, fulfilling the unexpected needs of the child. Just living with my husband after 10 years on my own is challenging - and we have separate bedrooms, in part, because of this. The idea of having another person around that I have to interact with for the next (at least) 18 years honestly feels like a significant hardship. I do not doubt I would develop feelings of love for the child (cognitive dissonance mostly takes care of that), but when I envision the realities of parenthood I view the majority of it as difficult and unenjoyable.

Also, just because smoking and obesity kill more than pregnancy does not mitigate my view that pregnancy (for me) would be a horrible experience that I do not want to endure.

I will stand by my decision to be *proud* of any abortion that I might need to have in order to preserve my well-being, identity, passions and goals: just as I appreciate those having children as it fulfills their dreams. The shame-inducing culture around abortion is unnecessary and hurts women. I do not view a fetus or fertilized egg as life - the arguments in the video are not at all significant.

Jessica Valenti's book, Why Have Kids?: A New Mom Explores the Truth About Parenting and Happiness - covers a lot of the reasons for my childfree choice in more detail.

To address the religious issue. If a higher power exists, it is degrading to women for it to be male. A sole, female god would also be degrading to men. This puts to much power in one gender. I would accept a non-gendered god or polytheistic faith. I can not endorse or believe a faith that supports a patriarchy. Although women may be an active part of the Catholic church - they are banned from leadership: clear misogyny. While I certainly believe in freedom of religion and do not discriminate by religion: it is critical to recognize the sexist and degrading themes of most prominent faiths.


Also, I found your blog while looking for works by other women who run and are successful, and have enjoyed following along. That is all - I was merely trying to shed light on the other perspective: that a pregnancy is not universally a blessing or a joy - and nine months of physical and psychological suffering should not be the mandated outcome for an unwanted pregnancy.

Amanda said...

I guess we can all be thankful that we don't live with that person! Good Lord, I have never encountered such a negative person before. Thank you so much for posting your response on here! Too often, bloggers are afraid to post their opinions. We all tip-toe around each others feelings. It's absolutely ridiculous. Everyone deserves to post whatever the Hell they want on their blog, without being attacked by others. If you don't like it, then leave. Simple as that.

Kelly-Belly said...

Thank you for standing up for what you believe in. I know it is a touchy subject, but I am very pro-life.

As far as the Freakanomics book, the "data" will tell you whatever you want it to...if you torture it long enough.

meghan miller said...

just read these posts. makes my heart ache for one who would feel burdened by a child. doctoring is great (most of the time) but mothering is way way better in my opinion. can't wait for you to experience it!

i also smiled a tear at your mom's comment so proud of her daughter :)

Julesdoobiedoo said...

I am proud of you for your response and holding true to your beliefs! Congratulations on your new little blessing! Being a mother has been by far the most rewarding thing that I've every done! I also wanted to point out to this person that while God may be referred to as a "he" the Bible teaches that man and woman were both made in his image which means that he has both male and female qualities. If you were to study and become very familiar with the teachings of the Bible, you would understand the true value of women in the eyes of the Lord!

Modern Camelot said...

I just read the commenter's response, and I am so amazed by it. I am also a Catholic pro-lifer, although I'm pretty liberal as far as most areas of Catholicism go, and I wasn't actually truly pro-life until I was pregnant and saw my daughter on an ultrasound at 12 weeks old already looking like a person - and knowing that, in my state, I'd still have time to abort her if I wanted to. She was sucking her thumb at that appointment - you can't tell me that life hadn't started yet.

Its great that that woman knows she doesn't want kids, but she sounds like a nightmare. Separate rooms from her husband? And some other serious mental hang ups.

I'm sorry, but if you have that much animosity towards the idea of a family, then you don't have sex. Abortion is not a form of birth control (something that, even as a Catholic, I am okay with certain types of - if people are goi ng to have sex anyway, and it keeps them from having abortions, I am okay with condoms, diaphragms, etc.) Gahhh...what a nutso post!

Heather @ Pretty Strong Medicine said...

Hi Emily!

I just stumbled across your blog as I am a soon-to-be medical student and I'm always looking to connect with others in our field.

I realize I'm a little late to the party on this comment but I just wanted to thank you for standing up for what you believe in and doing so in such an eloquent, graceful way. As a fellow Catholic woman, it is so encouraging to see women of faith as physicians. You don't have to compromise your beliefs in order to study science and medicine.

Thank you again and I look forward to reading more of your blog! Feel free to check mine out if you get a chance, I'm just getting started!

Heather

 
site design by designer blogs